8 Rarest Silver Eagle Coins Ever Minted

| |

American Silver Eagle was first released on November 24, 1986. This bullion coin contains one troy ounce of 99.9% pure silver and has a nominal face value of one dollar. The obverse features the iconic Walking Liberty, a design by Adolph A. Weinman. The reverse was designed by former chief engraver of the United States Mint John Mercanti. However, the reverse design was revised in 2021. The latest coins feature the artwork of Emily Damstra. Besides the bullion coins, the US mint occasionally released Proof and uncirculated versions of Silver Eagle for the collectors. The Silver Eagle has been minted in three mints, San Francisco Mint, Philadelphia Mint, and West Point Mint. Here we list 8 of the rarest Silver Eagle coins ever produced by the US mint. Many of them were special issues, released in low numbers to commemorate some event.

2006-P Reverse Proof Silver Eagle

2006-P Reverse Proof Silver Eagle
photo source: PCGS

Mintage: 248,875
Mint: Philadelphia
Highest auction price: $3,025

2006-P Reverse Proof was released as part of a three-piece set to commemorate the 20th anniversary of the Silver Eagle coin program. The other two coins in that set were a burnished Silver Eagle coin struct in West Point Mint and a regular proof Silver Eagle. The former was the first uncirculated Silver Eagle that had a W mint mark. The set was launched on August 30, 2006. The mintage was the second lowest in the Proof Silver Eagle series. The design of the coin feature mirror-like luster, and the field is frosty. The three-piece set was priced at $100 each, and no household was allowed to purchase more than 10 sets. The stock was depleted by mid-September. By then, the price was increased to double or more in the secondary market. One example of this coin was sold for $3,025 at the Great Collections Coin Auction on September 16, 2012.

2019-W Enhanced Reverse Proof Silver Eagle

2019-W Enhanced Reverse Proof Silver Eagle
photo source: PCGS

Mintage: 110,000
Mint: West Point
Highest Auction Price: $910

2019-W Enhanced Reverse Proof Siver Eagle was sold as part of the Pride of Two Nations silver coin set. It was a collaborative effort between The United States Mint and Royal Canadian Mint. The set included a special version of the Canadian Silver Maple Leaf coin and this one. The Canadian coin was minted at the Ottawa Mint, and the US coin was struck at the West Point Mint. The Canadian coin featured a proof finish and a modified reverse design, and the American featured a reverse cameo proof finish. A total of 110,000 sets were released; 100,000 were sold in the US and the rest in Canada. 

2011-S and 2011-P Reverse Proof Silver Eagle

2011-S and 2011-P Reverse Proof Silver Eagle
photo source: PCGS

Mintage: 99,882 each
Mint: San Francisco and Philadelphia, respectively
Highest Auction Price: $1,541 and $1,495

2011-S and 2011-P Reverse Proof Silver Eagle coins were released as part of the American Eagle 25th Anniversary Silver Coin Set. Both had the same mintage of 99,882.  The set had a total of five coins: one uncirculated coin minted at San Francisco Mint, one reserved proof coin minted at Philadelphia Mint, one proof coin and one proof coin and one uncirculated coin minted at West Point Mint, and one bullion coin. The set came in a beautiful, lacquered presentation case.

2020-W V75 Silver Eagle

2020-W V75 Silver Eagle
photo source: PCGS

Mintage: 75,000
Mint: West Point
Highest Auction Price: $780

2020-W V75 Proof Silver Eagle,along with its gold counterpart, was released on November 5, 2020. These special coins were released to commemorate the 75th anniversary of the end of World War II in 1945.  2020-W V75 Proof was the first Silver Eagle that had a privy mark. The privy mark on the obverse of the coin reads “V75”. The coin had a limited mintage of 75,000 and is rare to find.

2008-W Silver Eagle with Reverse of 2007

2008-W Silver Eagle with Reverse of 2007
photo source: PCGS

Mintage: 45,000
Mint: West Point
Highest Auction Price: $1,700

It is the only known error coin in the Silver Eagles series. US Mint brought some changes in the reverse design of Silver Eagles, including proofs, from 2008 onwards. On March 17, 2008, 2008-W Uncirculated Silver Eagles were released featuring the new design. The Burnished Uncirculated coins were directly sold to the collectors. About a month later, it was found by John Nanney from Georgia that some of the new coins had the reverse design from the previous batch. While investigating the issue, the Mint found that at least 15 reverse dies from the previous year were used to strike the new coin. So, they estimated that around 45,000 Uncirculated collector’s edition Silver Eagles were released with the wrong reverse design.

1995 10th Anniversary Eagle Set

1995 10th Anniversary Eagle Set
photo source: PCGS

Mintage: 30,125
Mint: West Point
Highest Auction Price: $16,450

A five-coin set of Proof coins were released by the United State Mint to celebrate the 10th anniversary of the Silver Eagle bullion coin program. It is the first anniversary set in the Silver Eagle series. The set included four Proof American Gold Eagles and one Proof American Silver Eagle. The Silver Proof was struck in the West Point Mint and marked with a “W”. In fact, it is the first W Proof Silver Eagle. This coin is highly sought after mainly due to its low mintage. A total of 30,125 sets were ever sold of this set.

2019-S Enhanced Reverse Proof

2019-S Enhanced Reverse Proof
photo source: PCGS

Mintage: 29,910
Mint: San Francisco
Highest Auction Price: $5,760

2019-S Enhanced Reverse Proof is the rarest Silver Eagle ever released by the US Mint. The coin was officially released on November 14, 2019. The coins were sold out within 20 minutes after it was launched. Over 100,000 people queued up online and in person from the previous night to get their hands on this rarest issue of Silver Eagle. A restriction of one coin per household was in place. The price of the coin jumped up in the secondary market as soon as the inventory was diminished at the Mint. Collectors expressed their dissatisfaction with how the Mint authorities handled the situation.

More From Rarest.Org

20 Most Expensive Fashion Stores in the World

Image Editorial Credit: Robert Way / Shutterstock

When it comes to luxury shopping, the world’s most expensive fashion stores are not just about clothing; they are about the experience of opulence and exclusivity. From the plush interiors to the impeccably tailored collections, these stores offer high-end fashion from iconic brands like Chanel, Hermès, and Gucci. Read more.

17 Most Expensive Mangoes in the World

Image Editorial Credit: hungryworks / Shutterstock

Mangoes, often hailed as the king of fruits, are celebrated worldwide for their irresistible sweetness and lush texture. While mangoes are generally affordable and widely available, certain varieties stand apart due to their rarity, cultivation methods, and exquisite flavors, commanding astronomical prices. Read more.

The 20 Wealthiest Cities in Georgia Based on Median Household Income

Image Editorial Credit: Darryl Brooks / Shutterstock

In the heart of the South, Georgia’s economic landscape is a vibrant mix of bustling metropolises and serene suburban communities. This article delves into the wealthiest cities within the Peach State, ranked by median household income, highlighting areas where affluence and prosperity have become the defining characteristics. Read more.

rarest_alvin

Head of Content at Rarest.org

Previous

The 17 Rarest Muscle Cars Ever Made

10 Most Expensive Restaurants in Washington D.C.

Next

Leave a Comment