8 Rare Board Game Expansions Worth a Small Fortune

Board game expansions can add depth and variety to your favorite games, but some rare expansions are worth more than you might expect. These obscure and highly sought-after expansions, often out of print or produced in limited quantities, have gained value over time and are now considered collector’s items. Whether you’re a dedicated fan or a collector looking to complete your set, these expansions can fetch surprising prices, sometimes exceeding the cost of the base game itself.

Fireball Island: The Curse of Vul-Kar Expansion

Released in the 1980s, Fireball Island quickly became a cult classic for its innovative 3D board design and adventurous gameplay. The Curse of Vul-Kar expansion adds new twists and treasures to the base game, pushing its value up to over $600 in mint condition. The expansion increases replayability and complexity by introducing new paths, more dangerous fireballs, and additional challenges for players. The intricate, molded island design continues to capture the imagination of collectors, particularly since a complete set in near-mint condition is a rarity. The expansion’s unique mechanics, including the massive marble drops and added obstacles, provide dynamic gameplay experiences that can’t be found in most modern games. Owning both the original game and this rare expansion can push the total collection value into the thousands. The game also saw a re-release in 2018, but the original expansion remains significantly more valuable, particularly among vintage collectors.

Cthulhu Wars Expansions

Cthulhu Wars is another high-end board game known for its massive miniatures and epic gameplay, with expansions such as Opener of the Way and Yog-Sothoth commanding steep prices. A complete set of these expansions can easily fetch upwards of $300 to $400, and in some cases, even higher. The expansions introduce new factions, each with its own abilities and strategies, significantly altering the game’s dynamics. Limited print runs and the high production quality of the miniatures make these expansions particularly valuable to collectors. Furthermore, the expansions often include additional maps and scenarios, increasing replayability.

War of the Ring: Collector’s Edition Expansion

The War of the Ring: Collector’s Edition and its expansions have become some of the most valuable board game items on the market. Originally released in limited numbers, the expansions add new miniatures, cards, and rules to an already expansive game. These expansions regularly sell for $400 to $500, with the collector’s edition often exceeding those numbers, especially if all pieces are included. The collector’s edition version is particularly sought after because of its intricate hand-painted miniatures and high-quality components. This expansion deepens the strategic and thematic elements, recreating the epic battles from J.R.R. Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings.

Twilight Imperium Fourth Edition: Prophecy of Kings Expansion

The Prophecy of Kings expansion for Twilight Imperium Fourth Edition is one of the most popular and expansive add-ons for this already epic space opera game. Released in 2020, the expansion adds seven new factions, more player options, and an assortment of new ships and leaders. Its value has skyrocketed, with mint-condition sets selling for $200 to $300 due to its transformative effect on gameplay. It allows for larger player counts and introduces new mechanics, such as leaders and exploration, drastically changing how the game is played. The quality of components, including highly detailed miniatures and vibrant artwork, further justifies the high price tag.

StarCraft: The Board Game – Brood War Expansion

The Brood War expansion for StarCraft: The Board Game is one of the most expensive expansions for any board game, regularly selling for $200 to $300. Released by Fantasy Flight Games, the expansion introduces new factions, units, and technologies, adding significant strategic depth to an already complex game. Its limited print run and connection to the beloved StarCraft video game franchise have driven up its value on the secondary market. The expansion also includes new scenarios and missions, which enhance replayability and make it a must-have for fans of the base game.

Descent: Journeys in the Dark – The Chains That Rust Expansion

Descent: Journeys in the Dark is a popular dungeon-crawling board game, and its Chains That Rust expansion has become a valuable collector’s item. Priced between $150 and $200, this expansion introduces new monsters, quests, and heroes to the base game. Its scarcity is due to a relatively short print run, making it harder to find as more players seek to complete their Descent collections. The expansion’s detailed miniatures and additional campaign content make it an essential purchase for fans of the game. The expansion also includes new mechanics that change how players interact with the dungeon and enemies, making it a dynamic addition to the Descent series.

BattleLore: Call to Arms Expansion

The Call to Arms expansion for BattleLore offers new customization options for building armies, making it a must-have for fans of the base game. A complete set of this expansion typically sells for $150 to $200. The expansion allows players to draft and deploy armies in new ways, significantly altering the game’s tactical elements. Due to its limited print run, it has become increasingly difficult to find, driving up its value on the secondary market. The expansion’s additional scenarios and rules enhance the overall gameplay experience, making it a highly sought-after item for strategy enthusiasts.

Battlestar Galactica: Daybreak Expansion

The Daybreak expansion for Battlestar Galactica: The Board Game adds new characters, ships, and scenarios, enriching the already immersive gameplay. This expansion can cost between $150 and $200, depending on its condition and whether all components are intact. It also introduces new mechanics, such as the Rebel Basestar and the Demetrius ship, which provide additional strategies and fresh challenges for players. The expansion further deepens the narrative, giving players more options for how they manage the iconic conflicts within the Battlestar universe. Given the limited number of expansions produced, Daybreak remains a must-have for fans of the series and continues to rise in value, particularly when found complete and in good condition.

This article originally appeared on Rarest.org.

More from Rarest.org

15 Fascinating Lizards with Color-Changing Abilities

Lizards with color-changing abilities are some of the most fascinating creatures in the animal kingdom. These reptiles can shift their hues for various reasons, from blending into their surroundings to communicating with other lizards. Read More.

Concept cars have always been a playground for designers and engineers to push the boundaries of what’s possible in the automotive world. While many of these imaginative vehicles never make it to production, they offer a glimpse into the future of car design, technology, and innovation. Read More.

Championship games are where legends are made, but they can also be where the most unexpected outcomes unfold. Throughout sports history, we’ve witnessed shocking upsets that defied all predictions and left fans in disbelief. Read More.