11 Discontinued Toys from the ’80s and ’90s That Now Fetch High Prices

| |

The toys from the ’80s and ’90s hold a special place in the hearts of collectors today. These iconic items, once seen in every household, have now become highly sought after due to their rarity and nostalgic appeal. Many of them have been discontinued, making them even more valuable. 

My Buddy Doll

My Buddy Doll
Image Editorial Credit: Kendrick Shackleford / Flickr

The My Buddy Doll was a popular toy in the late ’80s, designed as a companion for young children. Its iconic look, featuring a baseball cap and overalls, made it a hit. Today, collectors hunt for original dolls in good condition, and prices for a pristine My Buddy can reach around $100 to $300. Sealed versions or those in mint condition with their original packaging can go even higher, pushing past the $500 mark.

Cabbage Patch Kids (Original Edition)

Cabbage Patch Kids (Original Edition)
Image Editorial Credit: Bernard Gotfryd / Wikimedia Commons

The original Cabbage Patch Kids from the early ’80s became a cultural phenomenon, and their value has only risen. While newer editions are relatively affordable, original 1980s dolls in mint condition, especially those with rare features, can sell for up to $1,000 or more. Rare versions, like the Little People dolls, often fetch prices over $3,000.

Masters of the Universe Action Figures

Masters of the Universe Action Figures
Image Editorial Credit: semihundido / Flickr

Masters of the Universe action figures, especially key characters like He-Man and Skeletor, have become extremely collectible. Pristine, unopened figures can now sell for hundreds to thousands of dollars. On average, a mint-condition He-Man or Skeletor figure fetches around $200 to $500, with rarer figures, such as Scare Glow, commanding prices upwards of $1,000.

Nintendo Power Glove

Nintendo Power Glove
Image Editorial Credit: Evan-Amos / Wikimedia Commons

The Nintendo Power Glove, released in 1989, was a cutting-edge accessory for its time. Despite its limited functionality, it has gained a cult following. Complete sets in good condition typically sell for $200 to $400. However, sealed or mint-condition Power Gloves can go for as much as $800 to $1,200 due to their rarity and nostalgic value.

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Action Figures

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Action Figures
Image Editorial Credit: Burcu Ergin / Shutterstock

The original Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles action figures, produced by Playmates Toys, are highly collectible today. Characters like Leonardo, Michelangelo, and Shredder in unopened packaging can fetch between $100 to $500 each. Rarer figures, like Scratch the Cat, have been known to reach prices over $1,000 in pristine condition.

Lite-Brite (Vintage Editions)

Lite-Brite (Vintage Editions)
Image Editorial Credit: thomas ambridge / Wikimedia Commons

Lite-Brite, introduced in the late ’60s, remained popular throughout the ’80s and ’90s. Vintage editions of Lite-Brite, especially those in original packaging or with all components intact, now command prices ranging from $100 to $250. Collectors value the nostalgia and unique experience this toy offered, and sealed sets or early versions fetch even higher prices, sometimes surpassing $500.

Tamagotchi (First Edition)

Tamagotchi (First Edition)
Image Editorial Credit: Tomasz Sienicki / Wikimedia Commons

The first edition of Tamagotchi, launched in 1996, became a global sensation as one of the original virtual pets. Its small, egg-shaped design and simple gameplay captivated millions. Now, these early versions are in high demand. A well-preserved first-edition Tamagotchi can sell for $100 to $300, while sealed, mint-condition versions fetch even higher prices, often reaching $600 to $800.

Micro Machines (Original Sets)

Micro Machines (Original Sets)
Image Editorial Credit: Toxophilus / Wikimedia Commons

Micro Machines were tiny toy vehicles that gained massive popularity for their intricate designs and variety. Original sets from the late ’80s and early ’90s are now rare. Collectors are willing to pay $50 to $200 for complete sets in good condition. Special edition sets or those still in their original packaging can command prices of $400 or more, depending on their rarity.

Game Boy (Original Edition)

Game Boy (Original Edition)
Image Editorial Credit: Sammlung der Medien und Wissenschaft / Wikimedia Commons

The original Game Boy, launched by Nintendo in 1989, revolutionized handheld gaming. Today, this early version remains highly collectible. Prices for working Game Boys in good condition range from $100 to $250. Sealed or pristine versions, particularly those with original packaging, can sell for upwards of $800, making it a must-have for gaming collectors.

Talkboy (Home Alone 2 Edition)

Talkboy (Home Alone 2 Edition)
Image Editorial Credit: Y2kcrazyjoker4 / Wikimedia Commons

The Talkboy, made famous by the movie Home Alone 2, became a must-have toy in the early ’90s. Though its popularity waned after the film’s release, collectors now pay top dollar for this nostalgic item. A Talkboy in decent condition can sell for around $100 to $300. Sealed or pristine Talkboys, especially those with original packaging, have been known to fetch up to $500.

Skip-It (First Edition)

Skip-It (First Edition)
Image Editorial Credit: Saskatoon Public Library / Wikimedia Commons

The original Skip-It, a popular outdoor toy, captured kids’ attention in the late ’80s and early ’90s with its colorful design and counting feature. Today, the first edition Skip-It is a valuable collectible. Prices for this toy range from $50 to $150 depending on condition, with mint versions reaching up to $300 when accompanied by original packaging.

This article originally appeared on Rarest.org.

More from Rarest.org

19 Stunning Perennial Flowers That Attract Butterflies and Bees

Coneflower (Echinacea)
Image Editorial Credit: Kirk Gulden / Shutterstock

Butterflies and bees are essential pollinators, and one of the best ways to attract them is by planting beautiful perennial flowers. Read More.

12 Ancient Forms of Storytelling That Shaped Cultural Identity

Oral Traditions storytelling
Image Editorial Credit: Biblioteca Juvenil Mayaguez / Wikimedia Commons

Storytelling has always been at the heart of human culture. From ancient times, people found ways to share stories that shaped their beliefs, values, and traditions. Read More.

12 Rare Vintage Military Memorabilia and What They’re Worth Now

World War I Doughboy Helmet
Image Editorial Credit: Mikeofv / Wikimedia Commons

Rare vintage military memorabilia offers collectors a fascinating glimpse into history. These items hold not only sentimental value but significant financial worth. Read More.

rarest_alvin

Head of Content at Rarest.org

Previous

15 Abandoned Amusement Park Rides Now Considered Valuable Collectibles

Leave a Comment